Oxylabs vs NetNut (2026): ISP Proxies Head-to-Head
Verdict: How to Choose
Oxylabs and NetNut are both serious enterprise providers, but they come from different angles:
- Choose Oxylabs if: You want a full product suite (residential, ISP, datacenter, SERP API, Web Scraper API) and prefer a single vendor. The managed scraping layer is Oxylabs’ differentiator.
- Choose NetNut if: ISP proxies are your primary use case, you need a long cookie lifetime (1-year), or your volume qualifies for NetNut’s high-ticket affiliate tier ($5,000 cap vs. Oxylabs’ $2,000 cap).
NetNut is an ISP-proxy specialist; Oxylabs is a full-stack provider. If ISP proxies are only part of your stack, Oxylabs’ breadth wins. If ISP is the whole stack, test both.
Comparison Table (Measured)
| Metric | Oxylabs | NetNut |
|---|---|---|
| Success rate (overall) | measuring | measuring |
| Avg latency — ISP proxies | measuring | measuring |
| Block rate — Amazon | measuring | measuring |
| Block rate — Google SERP | measuring | measuring |
| Pool type focus | Residential + ISP + DC | ISP-first (residential, rotating) |
| Countries | 195 | 90+ |
| Pricing from (ISP) | ~$1.80/IP/month | ~$1.50/IP/month |
| Pricing from (residential) | ~$12/GB | ~$9/GB |
| Free trial | 7-day | Contact sales |
| Cookie lifetime | Standard | Up to 1 year |
| Affiliate | 50% first sale, $2,000 cap | Up to 50%, $5,000 cap, 1-year cookie |
Benchmark figures updating — see /benchmark/ for live data.
Performance Difference
ISP proxies route through real ISP ASNs, making them harder to detect than datacenter proxies while being faster and more consistent than rotating residential. The key differentiators between Oxylabs and NetNut at this tier are:
- Session persistence: NetNut’s 1-year cookie lifetime is exceptional. Oxylabs offers standard sticky sessions (minutes to hours). If your workflow requires long-running authenticated sessions, NetNut wins clearly.
- Geo depth: Oxylabs covers 195 countries across all proxy types. NetNut’s ISP network covers 90+ countries — sufficient for major markets, potentially limiting for niche geo requirements.
- Suite breadth: Oxylabs includes residential, datacenter, mobile, and managed APIs. NetNut is narrower in product coverage.
Measured data will confirm or revise these structural differences — see /benchmark/.
Pricing Winner
For ISP proxy access specifically, NetNut is marginally cheaper per IP per month and has a lower residential GB rate. For teams that need the full Oxylabs suite (including managed APIs), the additional cost buys meaningful capability beyond raw ISP proxy access.
Best by Use Case
| Use Case | Recommended | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Long-session monitoring (brand protection) | NetNut | 1-year cookie lifetime; persistent sessions |
| Price monitoring (frequent rotation) | Oxylabs | Residential pool depth + managed retry layer |
| SERP tracking | Oxylabs | SERP Scraper API |
| Ad verification (niche geos) | Oxylabs | 195-country coverage |
| High-ticket affiliate / reseller | NetNut | $5,000 cap, 1-year cookie |
| Lean tech stack (ISP only) | NetNut | ISP-specialist network |
See: brand protection guide, price monitoring guide.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | Oxylabs | NetNut |
|---|---|---|
| ISP / static residential | ✓ | ✓ (primary product) |
| Residential rotating | ✓ | ✓ |
| Datacenter | ✓ | Limited |
| Mobile | ✓ | — |
| Web Scraper API | ✓ | — |
| SERP API | ✓ | — |
| Long-session persistence | Standard | Up to 1 year |
| Country coverage | 195 | 90+ |
| Free trial | 7-day | Sales contact |
FAQ
What are ISP proxies and why do they matter?
ISP proxies are IP addresses assigned by real internet service providers (like AT&T or Comcast) but hosted in datacenters. They combine the clean reputation of residential IPs with the speed and reliability of datacenter infrastructure. Most bot-detection systems treat them as legitimate residential traffic.
Which is better for Amazon scraping?
For Amazon specifically, ISP proxies perform well because Amazon’s detection focuses on known datacenter IP ranges. Both Oxylabs and NetNut should handle Amazon at moderate volume. Our harness is measuring block rates — see /benchmark/.
Is NetNut’s 1-year session really useful?
For brand protection monitoring (watching for trademark violations, counterfeit listings, unauthorized sellers) and persistent price watching on accounts that require login, yes — long sessions mean fewer re-authentications and less exposure. For rotation-heavy scraping, session length doesn’t matter.
Can I switch from Oxylabs to NetNut (or vice versa)?
Both support standard HTTP/HTTPS proxy protocols, so switching is an endpoint and credential change with minimal code change. Test both via trial before committing to volume pricing.
This article was produced with AI assistance and reviewed by an editor. Pricing and specs as of 2026-05-31. Benchmark figures measured via free trial — see /benchmark/. Use proxies for legitimate purposes only.